Table 4

Study findings and quality appraisal

Study author, yearInterventionWork outcomesPopulationKey findingsDirection of supportQuality
Killacky, 200832 40 Tailored supported employmentCompetitive employment
Employed in any job
Income
Hours worked
Mental healthTreatment group significantly more likely to report competitive employment
Treatment group significantly more likely to report competitive employment
Treatment group reported significantly greater income
Treatment group reported significantly greater hours worked
+
+
+
+
H
Burke-Miller et al, 201233 Tailored supported employmentEmployed in any job
Competitive employment
Mental healthYoung adult treatment group more likely to report working in any job (ns)
Young adult treatment group significantly more likely to report competitive employment
+
+
H
Ferguson, 201234 Tailored supported employmentEmployed in any job
Hours worked
Income
Mental healthTreatment group significantly more likely to report employment in any job
No difference between treatment and control group in hours worked
No difference between treatment and control group in hours worked
+
/
/
M
Fraker et al, 201841 Youth transition demonstration enhanced employment servicesEmployment in any job
Income
Any disability*Treatment group significantly more likely to report employment in any job
Treatment group reported significantly greater income
+
+
M
Major et al, 201035 Tailored supported employmentCompetitive employmentMental healthTreatment group significantly more likely to report competitive employment+M
McGahey et al, 201436 Tailored supported employment+self-disclosure  Planning +Competitive employmentMental healthTreatment group significantly more likely to report competitive employment+M
Wehman et al, 201738 Tailored supported employment+autism spectrum disorder specific interventionCompetitive employmentIntellectual and learning disabilityTreatment group significantly more likely to report competitive employment+H
Wehman et al, 201437 Tailored supported employmentCompetitive employmentIntellectual and learning disabilityTreatment group significantly more likely to report competitive employment+M
Smith et al, 201542 Technology-based job interview trainingCompetitive employmentIntellectual and learning disabilityTreatment group significantly more likely to report competitive employment+M
Yamaguchi et al, 201631 Tailored supported employment+cognitive  remediationCompetitive employment
Job tenure
Mental healthTreatment group significantly more likely to report competitive employment
Treatment group significantly more likely to report longer job tenure
+
+
M
  • *Any disability includes those living with  mental health, intellectual/learning, physical and/or speech/hearing/visual disability.

  • +, positive effect; /, no effect, H, high quality; M, medium quality; ns, not statistically significant.